|
SEX DIFFERENCES
IN PUBIC HAIR DISTRIBUTION The distribution of
pubic hair has long been regarded as a secondary sex character. Attention
has been directed especially to the upper border of the pubes; a horizontal
line of termination has come to be regarded as feminine, one that pointed
towards the umbilicus as masculine. Exceptions of this rule have been found
regularly. A more extensive investigation of this subject, utilizing an
adequate sample of the population, therefore, is of obvious value.
Method and Material The pubic hair pattern
was studied in photographs of 400 men and
400 women. For convenience of presentation they have been divided into age
groups by decades. Although all of these groups are selected, for the purpose
of the present investigation, they may be considered as a valid sample of
the general population. Volunteers with diseases, which were considered
to have a possible influence on hair growth, were excluded. 80 pregnant
women formed an additional series.*
Preliminary examination
of this material showed that the distribution of pubic hair can be classified
for practical purposes into four fundamental types, illustrated in Fig.
1. The first, or horizontal type, is characterized by terminating superiorly
in a horizontal line. This corresponds to the classical feminine distribution.
The second, or sagittal type, resembles the first except, for an additional
linear upward extension in the mid-line, ranging from a few scattered hairs,
a definite streak of hairs confined to this line, to a thin band of hair
arranged on either side of this line. The third, or acuminate type, corresponds
to the classical masculine distribution, the upward extension being triangular
in shape (inverted V-shaped), pointing towards the umbilicus. In the fourth,
or disperse type, hair is distributed over the abdomen without forming a
discrete geometrical pattern.
This classification
is concerned with the character of the upper border of the pubic hair. There
are numerous other features, such as the luxuriance of hair development,
differential distribution in the genital region and degree of extension
on to the thigh, which are of interest. Their inclusion in the present study
would lead to undue complication.
In addition to the classification
of pubic hair pattern, approximate quantitative estimates were made of the
degree of hirsutism exhibited by the anterior aspect of the thigh and the
chest for all men. In the original observations, the amount of hair was
recorded in three categories; sparse, moderate and dense. In order to simplify
the presentation, the moderate and dense categories have been combined into
one, which is termed conspicuous. The age groups have been summarized into
two major groups; the 15 - 24 age group, and the combination of the age
groups ranging from 25 - 64.
As a necessary preliminary
to an investigation into the clinical significance of excessive hair growth
in women, observations were made of the normal variability of facial hair
growth of upper lip and chin in all women. Four grades of hair growth were
distinguished at each of the two sites. Minor degrees of hair growth constituted
the grades 1 and 2. More servere degrees were placed in grades 3 and 4.
Fig. 1Discussion The frequency with which
the various Types of pubic hair distribution occurred in our series, is
summarized in Table 1. The horizontal type
of pubic hair distribution, found in the 15 - 24 age group, is surprisingly
high. At this age 38.6 per cent of the men have a horizontal pubic pattern,
while 49.1 per cent show the acuminate type. Under these circumstances it
is scarcely appropriate to call the horizontal pattern "feminine" and the
acuminate "masculine." In the older age groups of men, there is a decrease
in the horizontal type from 17, 7 per cent to 8 per cent, the acuminate
type remaining approximately constant. It is particularly interesting to
note, that in the 25 - 64 age groups the disperse pattern appears in 27
per cent of the cases. This pattern is characterized by general hairiness
of the suprapubic region and its appearance is correlated with general increase
in hirsutism with age.
The correlation between
the upward extension of pubic hair and the development of chest and thigh
hair is apparent from the data presented in Table
2. In the 15 - 24 age group 46 per cent of the men with sparse chest
hair have a horizontal pattern of pubic hair, while only 5 per cent of the
individuals with conspicuous chest hair show this pubic pattern. The corresponding
for the older age group are 35 per cent and 3 per cent. Of the men in the
15 - 24 age group, who have only sparse hairiness of the thigh 79 per cent
exhibit the horizontal pubic pattern, compared with 28 per cent in the men
with conspicuous thigh hairiness. The older men yield corresponding figures
of 41 per cent and 4 per cent respectively.
General hirsutism is
consequently an important, but not the only, factor determining pubic hair
distribution. The tendency towards general development of hair exhibits
itself earlier on the thigh than on the chest. Conspicuous thigh hair is
presented in 81 per cent of the 15 - 24 age group and 77 per cent of our
series of older men, but only 20 per cent of the 15 - 24 age group had conspicuous
chest hair, compared with 70 per cent of the older group.
In contrast to the men,
the pubic hair distribution in the women is preponderantly of the horizontal
type. (The percentage presenting the different degrees of growth becoming
progressively smaller the more extensive is the growth.) The incidence of
the acuminate type is with 17.1 per cent highest in the 15 - 24 age group,
remains approximately constant in the 25 - 44 age groups then suddenly falls
in the 45 - 64 age group, to only one person. It is significant, that the
acuminate pattern is found in 13.8 per cent of pregnant women. There is
consequently no indication of a correlation between fertility and pubic
hair pattern. This again emphasizes the inadvisability of using the term
"masculine" for the acuminate type of hair distribution. An extensive previous
investigation on hair growth in women is that of Fink [1].
His findings for the acuminate and sagittal pattern of hair growth are lower
than the obtained here, whereas our results are in fundamental agreement
with the da ta of Rodecurt [2], who demonstrated
that a substantial proportion of women show a degree of hair growth, that
departs from the "feminine" distribution. Studies on the development of
pubic hair (Priesel and Wagner [3], Greulich
[4]) also have shown, that the horizontal type
appears in both sexes at puberty.
It may consequently
be regarded as the basic pattern, from which the other types develop by
upward extension. The retention of the horizontal distribution as the definitive
type in most adult women, seems to be a result of general feminine characteristic
of paucity of body hair, rather than of a special factor affecting the pubic
region. In other words, it follows that body hair growth in both sexes should
be thought of in terms of degree, rather than of distribution.
The degree of facial
and abdominal hair growth shows considerable variation with age and hence
it is important for such changes to be taken into consideration in any study
on the correlation between hair growth and other physical characteristics.
In Table 3 are given the relative incidences
of minor (1 - 2) and major (3 - 4) degrees of hair growth on lip and chin
in correlation to the pubic pattern, by decades. The variation with age
in the incidence of the latter at these sites is shown graphically in Fig.
2.
No systematic correlation between abdominal and facial hair growth and general
body hair was attempted in the present investigation, but a strong impression
was gained, that the heavier degrees of general hirsuties in younger women
are found in those, presenting the major grades of facial hirsuties, combined
with the acuminate pubic pattern.
Observations on hair
growth in the older age groups in women are scanty. Our findings with respect
to facial hair growth differ somewhat from those, obtained by Trotter[5],
who found that the incidence of facial hypertrichosis gradually increased
from youth to old age, without a conspicuous change at any particular period.
Fig.
2
Percentages of hirsute Individuals Changes in the Incidence of facial and hypogastric hirsuties with age Summary Pubic hair distribution
has been examined in photographs of 400 men and 480 women. The classical
division into "masculine" and "feminine" types is found to be unsatisfactory.
An adequate classification recognizes four types, designated as horizontal,
sagittal, acuminate and disperse. The acuminate or "masculine" type is present
in 55 per cent of the men and 8 per cent of the women. It is also the basic
type for male adolescents, is characteristic of 39 per cent of the 15 -
24 age group and persists in 12 per cent of the adult males. In males the
decrease in frequency of the horizontal pattern with age is associated with
increase in general hirsutism and is accompanied by the development of a
disperse pubic hair pattern.
In the younger age groups
(15 - 34) of women, the existence of a substantial proportion of individuals
who depart from what is ordinarily considered to be "feminine" pattern of
hair growth is confirmed. It is likely that the difference in body hair
growth between males and females are a matter of degree rather than a reflection
of a more fundamental difference in hair distribution. After the fifth decade,
there is a striking increase in the incidence of facial hirsuties and, at
the same time, a reduction in the degree of pubic hair growth.
1 Fink, A. (1963). Metrische und morphologisch - anthropologische Untersuchungen an 440 österreichischen Frauen (Dissertation, Universität Wien.) 2 Rodecurt, M. (1934). Beobachtung über Nabel und Körperbehaarung beim Weibe (Zeit. f. Konst., 18 : 373.) 3 Priesel, R. u. Wagner, R. (1930). Gesetzmäßigkeit im Auftreten der extragenitalen sekundären Geschlechtsmerkmale bei Mädchen (Zeit. f. Konst., 15 : 333.) 4 Greulich, W.W. (1942). Somatic and endocrine studies of pubertal and adolescent boys (Monog. Soc. Res. Child Dev., 7 : No. 3.) 5 Trotter, M. (1921). A study of facial hair in white and black races. (Washington, Univ. Stud., 9 : 273 - 289); 1922, The incidence and heredity of facial hypertrichosis in white women (Am. J. Anthrop., 5 : 391 - 397.) Sample
Photos from Study |